Peacefield History

Teaching Critical Thinking Creatively

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Shop
    • Shop Teaching Materials on TpT
  • Community
    • Join our Email Community
    • Join our Collaborative Facebook Group
  • About Peacefield History

Teaching Evidence Based Argumentation through Games

By: peacefieldhistory1 Comment

Teaching Evidence Based Argumentation Through Games

NOTE: I had my students play JENGA again this school year. I modified the rules, and the game worked much better! I’ve decided to edit this post to include some the new details. Look below to see my updates!

Evidence-Based Argumentation through Games

Teaching History is often about expressing a point of view, and supporting that point of view with evidence. Obviously, practicing this skill involves lots of writing for students. Earlier in the school year, I had students interact through a silent conversation. I loved that process, and I’m fairly certain that students learned a lot through the experience. Still, that process was silent! I decided that I wanted to find a way where my students could practice this skill without having endless days of silent solitary writing during class time.  Therefore, I decided that I would try a new strategy – encouraging skilled argumentation through games.

The Ping Pong and Bucket Strategy

A few weeks ago, I posted about teaching argumentation through games on Instagram. I had my first game day, and my set up was fairly basic. I had a bucket and some ping pong balls. I would present the students with statements that had a clear point of view. Students were divided into two groups – agree and disagree. Each side had to come up with three points that supported their “agree” or “disagree” side of the statement given. If a student provided a sufficient argument with evidence to support their point of view, they could take a shot with a ping pong ball towards the bucket.

This strategy worked fairly well, and students were able to come up with great evidence to support their arguments. The only issue that came up with the process was my students’ aim! Some students were much better than others at aiming for the bucket. Therefore, the process became much more about who could throw a ping pong ball, than who could support an argument with evidence. I also found myself giving credit for almost every statement. I took this information from the first experience and asked my fabulous Instagram community for suggestions.

Introducing “Jackson Jenga”

Teaching Evidence Based Argumentation Through GamesOne of my followers suggested Jenga. (Unfortunately, I couldn’t remember who this was, and I couldn’t find her message in my direct messages.) Points could be added to the interior of the Jenga pieces. When students provided a winning piece of evidence, they could be called up to pull a Jenga piece. Instead of giving credit for all arguments, I would pick the better argument from each team.

I liked this version of the game much better. Jenga was hysterical fun, and because I chose between the two groups, the students had to articulate better arguments for each prompt. For this round, we played “Jackson Jenga, so each of the prompts was about Andrew Jackson. Here’s a sampling:

  1. The tariffs passed by Congress were unduly harsh on the southerners.
  2. Jackson was racist.
  3. Jackson was right to criticize the election of 1824 as unfair.
  4. Jackson should be removed from the 20 dollar bill.

Each of these statements has a clear point of view, however, these statements are also arguable. Therefore, each side has an equal chance.

This style of teaching and learning could be applied to so many scenarios. I could see utilizing this process to help students set up a DBQ in the future. Of course, I’ll keep you updated!

An Update..

This year I decided I would try the JENGA argument game again. I found it necessary to update the rules. I wanted my students to evaluate each others arguments. Therefore, I decided to divide the class into three teams. The teams would rotate each round – so that each time had a chance to play all three roles. Here are the rules below.

  1. You will be divided into three teams and the JENGA game will be set up in the middle of the class. 
  2. Taking turns – two of the three teams will be presented with a statement that they will have to argue. One will be the AGREE team and the other will be the DISAGREE team. Each team will present three points of support for their argument (one at a time).
  3. The third team will be the JUDGE team and decide which argument is better. The team that “won” the argument then gets to pull a JENGA piece for points. 
  4. Each round the teams rotate and a new team becomes the AGREE, DISAGREE or JUDGE team. 
  5. If the tower falls, your team loses. 

This process worked so much better! We had time for each of the three groups to play each of the roles. The kids were discussing the relative arguments – and the evidence for those arguments – each round. I didn’t have to do very much, because the kids evaluated each other. At the end of class, many of the kids told me that they loved the activity and that they wanted to do it every day! (This won’t happen.)

Here’s a link to a slideshow with the JENGA rules if you want to play in your classroom.

Have you used any games in your games to develop writing skills? 


Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here:

Cookie Policy

Trackbacks

  1. 10 Cooperative Learning Idea for a Socially Distanced Classroom - Peacefield History says:
    October 11, 2020 at 6:15 pm

    […] also recommend having your students practice playing some of these evidence-based argumentation games to practice their socratic skills. One of my favorites is Jenga. You can always use this digital […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Peacefield History

Peacefield History is filled with all topics teaching and history related. Follow me for trends in education, teacher tech tips, history related reading, and other more general musings.

Search

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Join the Facebook Group

Follow Me on Pinterest

Instagram

peacefieldhistory

I had a small win this Friday, and I needed it thi I had a small win this Friday, and I needed it this week. I told my AP students that I was excited about this quiz idea, and they laughed. Honestly, there’s not much to look forward to in a pandemic, and if an exciting quiz is it, well so be it. 

I took the idea of hexagonal review and turned it into a quiz. It was assigned in Google Slides, and I could see the minute they start editing, and the minute they finished. This also worked remotely, and it even worked for my students who have iffy internet. Zoom in to read the directions, and let me know if you have questions. (My Kardashian example is an inside joke with my AP kids.) 

#socialstudies #iteachhistory #iteachAP #socialstudiesteachersrock #iteachmiddleschool #iteachhistory #socialstudiestips #remoteteaching #hybridteaching
You are watching an insurrection. This is domesti You are watching an insurrection. 
This is domestic terrorism. 
This is not a representative Democracy. 

Period.
𝗝𝘂𝘀𝘁 𝗮𝘀𝗸𝗶𝗻𝗴???? ⁣ 𝗝𝘂𝘀𝘁 𝗮𝘀𝗸𝗶𝗻𝗴???? ⁣
⁣
I don't think we should be first on the list by any means... however, when I see teachers from other states getting that coveted shot in their arm, I wonder when it will be our turn. ⁣
⁣
I just want some information.⁣
⁣
#socialstudiesteacher #socialstudies #teachinghistory  #hybridlearning #weareteachers #teacherlife #middleschoolsteacher #teachersfollowteachers  #distancelearning #iteachhistory #
This post might be two days late, but that's becau This post might be two days late, but that's because I'm all about finding "balance" this year. Balance between...⁣
⁣
work/life⁣
school/home⁣
plenty/simplicity⁣
productivity/relaxation⁣
the past/ the future⁣
growth/contentment⁣
⁣
I can over think everything at every moment of the day. This year, I just want to live and savor the days instead. (This might just be because I'm 40 now, but I see those days as they pass, and they are fast y'all.)⁣
⁣
#socialstudiesteacher #socialstudies #teachinghistory #TpT #teacherspayteachers #teacherlife #middleschoolteacher #teachersfollowteachers  #distancelearning #iteachhistory #distancelearning  #engagingteaching #historyteacher #iteachmiddleschool #iteachAP #teacheronbreak
Accurate. Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to t Accurate.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to those who celebrate in this season! I’m just trying not to eat ALL the spinach and artichoke dip that I made... #selfcare #thedipistheselfcare
My students have been playing "For Crown or Colony My students have been playing "For Crown or Colony?" over the past week, and I needed a new way to make sure that they were understanding/paying attention to what they were learning from the game. I wanted this check-in to be quick, easy to mark, and with minimal clicking on my part. @Padlet came to my rescue. Here's how I set it up.⁣
⁣
1. I posted a question with directions. My post was the only item visible on the page.⁣
2. Student didn't have to log in, they just created their own posts and added their names at the top. ⁣
3. To prevents students from copying each other, I make the posts require approval. This way, I could see all the posts, but they could not. I could provide a check next to their names as I gradually approved the posts. ⁣
⁣
This worked. Students would review the posts the next day to see how their interactions with the game differed. It was easy and quick, and we all need more of that this year. I hope you're thriving and not just surviving right now in your classroom!⁣
⁣
Allison⁣
⁣
#socialstudiesteacher #socialstudies #teachinghistory #TpT #teacherspayteachers #hybridlearning #teacherlife #middleschoolsteacher #teachersfollowteachers #historyteacher #distancelearning #iteachhistory #distancelearning #cooperativelearning #padlet #missionus #forcrownorcolony  #iteachmiddleschool
So basically today was about how much I look like So basically today was about how much I look like my Bitmoji. 🤷🏻‍♀️ #greatkidslongyear #iteachmiddleschool #socialstudiesteacher #iteachhistory #hybridteaching #socialstudies #bitmoji #teachersofinstagram
I'm EXHAUSTED, but I'm starting to figure out how I'm EXHAUSTED, but I'm starting to figure out how this hybrid learning thing works. (It probably helps that I have the sweetest kids under the sun this year!) Since I've had a couple nights of actual sleep, I decided to blog about some of the ideas I've had for cooperative learning this year. It's definitely more difficult, but it's not impossible. (Especially since I've fallen in love with Google Breakout rooms.) Click the link in my profile to learn more!
I have a million tasks on my plate right now, but I have a million tasks on my plate right now, but I may have spent some of my Saturday rearranging my plants. Swipe to see some of my faves. (Yes I have fave plants, don’t you?!) 

#noregrets #havetograde #plantsaremyhappyplace #plantlady #houseplants #sundayvibes #homedecor #sundayscaries
The day after the President told teachers that the The day after the President told teachers that they were focusing too much on slavery in our history, we talked about slavery in my AP class. Why? It's a HUGE part of U.S. History, and not shocking, it also a HUGE part of my curriculum. Slavery comes up often in my classes because it's so fundamental to our development as a country. I'd traditionally done this lesson as a silent conversation, however, I decided to have my hybrid class use Jamboard instead for this lesson.  I gave them 8 "thought provoking" prompts. They had to respond using the ideas they generated by reading two articles (Nash and Kendi). Then, they had to respond to a classmate's posts on each slide. ⁣
⁣
It was an intense and silent period. Students were clicking, typing and THINKING. Their brains were flying and focused. It was interesting, when the bell rang it startled all of this. The initial feedback was that they really enjoyed the experience. We had nine slides filled with details and ideas. Of all that I have done with hybrid teaching thus far, this was probably my favorite. ⁣
⁣
I had a bit of a lightbulb go off with this experience. We're often tasks with "summing things up" at the end of every lesson. With this lesson, I made it about the PROCESS. Thinking, critical thinking, doesn't always lead to an immediate resolution. My students still learned, despite not having a summation.⁣
⁣
This is not my lesson. I've blogged about it previously, and all the resources are there. Click the link in my profile to grab them.
I had another post scheduled for this evening, but I had another post scheduled for this evening, but right now all I can think about is this tremendous loss and my concern for our country. She lived an admirable life, and the fears we have because of her death make me so sad. 

Image from @theimpeccablewoman
Since many of us teaching remotely in some form th Since many of us teaching remotely in some form these days,  I compiled a list of my favorite Youtube channels for teaching Middle School History.  You can check out my blog post by clicking the link in my profile.
One of the best things I did for myself this past One of the best things I did for myself this past year was revive my garden. It had fallen to pieces the previous year. I was overwhelmed by life, and the garden was way too big for just me. It had become a place of stress instead of joy. This year, I cut it in half and had my Dad help me rebuild the beds. With a smaller garden, I was able to maintain the space properly. It looks so much better, I grew veggies and flowers again, and I love going out there now!

Never forget to keep a space for yourself. Both a tangible space and one in your mind.
I had the BEST day with students today. I introduc I had the BEST day with students today. I introduced them to @pear_deck, and we were all able to collectively learn. They learned about the program, and I learned a bit more about them! I gave them a bunch of different kinds of questions to get them used to the platform. For one, they had to draw a historical event, and then their classmates had to guess which even they were drawing. I faced my  computer towards the screen so that both my in class students and my remote students could participate. It was so cool! Everyone had a chance to be a part of the conversation.

I still look serious here however, because despite these positive experiences, we all have to stay vigilant. Keep cleaning, socially distancing, and keep that mask on! I want to at least keep hybrid schooling in my life, and that will only happen if our cases stay low.

Get some rest this weekend!
So, my first day back with students went by in a f So, my first day back with students went by in a flash, so here’s a picture from the morning before the school day.

Honestly, for me today was pretty darn good. To see my AP kids in the room was just pure joy (I had them in seventh also.) The hybrid thing was weird, but we’ll get used to it. The seventh graders were still super cute - online or in person - and we all just seemed happy to be back. I know that it’s going to get more difficult, and I think that grading online is certainly going to kill me. However, I’m going to savor this moment. I just felt grateful to be back in my classroom. (Oh, and wearing a mask really wasn’t that bad.🤷🏻‍♀️)

I hope your day was good also, and if it wasn’t, I hope it gets better soon!
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Categories

  • AP U.S. History
  • Assessment
  • Book Reviews
  • Classroom Management
  • Digital Learning
  • Inquiry Based Learning
  • Lessons
  • Professional Development
  • Standards Based Grading
  • Teacher Budgeting
  • Teacher Interviews
  • Teacher Self Care
  • Teacher Tech
  • Teaching Strategies
  • Teaching the Election

Popular Posts

  • Designing your Social Studies Classroom Cheaply and Easily
    Designing your Social Studies Classroom Cheaply and Easily
  • 4 Fun Websites for Teaching Geography Interactively
    4 Fun Websites for Teaching Geography Interactively
  • 10 Hacks for Creating with Google Slides - Part 1
    10 Hacks for Creating with Google Slides - Part 1
  • 10 Cooperative Learning Idea for a Socially Distanced Classroom
    10 Cooperative Learning Idea for a Socially Distanced Classroom
  • Eight Youtube Channels for Teaching Middle School Social Studies
    Eight Youtube Channels for Teaching Middle School Social Studies
  • Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies
    Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies
  • My Favorite History Review Game of All Time!
    My Favorite History Review Game of All Time!
  • The Best Inquiry Based Social Studies Lessons on the Web
    The Best Inquiry Based Social Studies Lessons on the Web
  • A Critical Thinking One Pager Assessment
    A Critical Thinking One Pager Assessment
  • Keeping Students Organized With a Binder Organization System
    Keeping Students Organized With a Binder Organization System

Find me on Facebook

Find me on Facebook

© 2018–2021 Peacefield History.
  • Contact Me
  • Privacy Policy