Peacefield History

Teaching Critical Thinking Creatively

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Shop
    • Shop Teaching Materials on TpT
  • Community
    • Join our Email Community
    • Join our Collaborative Facebook Group
  • About Peacefield History

Black History Month Isn’t Enough

By: peacefieldhistory3 Comments

Black History Month Isn't Enough

This month (February) is Black History Month in the United States. Therefore, I’ve seen many posts around the internet that highlight the stories of individuals who had previously been written out of the narrative. I applaud this effort. I love seeing these stories utilized more in classrooms, and I think it’s great that educators are making a concerted effort to do so.

It’s Not Enough

Still, I think more needs to be done. History isn’t just the stories of individuals. When we discuss the history of the United States (or the history of the World) with our students, there is a predominant narrative that we share as educators. We might discuss that narrative through direct instruction. Or, we convey that narrative through the materials we include in our classrooms and the topics we encourage our students to investigate. The narrative we tell in our classes, the story we convey, the story our students investigate? That story needs some rewriting also.

The Story is Incomplete

The whole narrative needs to become more cognizant of the fact that there are actors in our history that were purposely left out of the history books and the storyline. They were left out because they were members of groups that were purposely being marginalized, or because they were reacting against the narrative of progress that U.S. History likes to promote. With that erasure, the story is incomplete. When we frame history without those stories, it really changes how the story is told.

Although Black History Month obviously highlights the history of Black Americans, this is also true for other ethnic groups that have been marginalized and written out of the narrative. (This same line can be drawn towards women’s history also.)

Woodrow Wilson and Racism – An Example

For example, if you’re a teacher of U.S. History, you’re probably aware of Woodrow Wilson. When I was in college, I had only studied the economic aspects of his presidency. Then, when I started teaching about his presidency, the textbook I utilized mostly talked about World War I and his stroke after pushing for the League of Nations. It’s a legitimately a sad story on some levels, as he had been so forthright in his attempts to have it passed that he pushed his health beyond repair.

The textbook I was utilizing mentioned Wilson’s racism, his showing of “Birth of a Nation” in the White House, and the continued segregation of the U.S. military. When I read this, my first thought was – yep. This makes sense, it’s “of the times.” The narrative failed to mention the push back from African Americans who questioned Wilson’s policies and his racism. If it was there, it was barely there.

Then, somewhere along the way, I read about the St. Louis massacre (often called the St. Louis Riots), and then the Silent March. All were a reflection of the tension brought about by the Great Migration and the competition for jobs. The Silent March (NYC 1917), was a reaction to the St. Louis massacre and lynchings around the country in general. Days later, a group of African Americans (including Madame C.J. Walker) brought a petition down to D.C. to deliver to Wilson. They wanted him to address the lynchings. He wouldn’t even meet with them.

A More Honest Narrative

When this little piece of the piece of the narrative is added back in, it really changes the story of Wilson. It wasn’t just that he continued the segregation of the past, he actively promoted that segregation and discrimination – even when he was faced with it head on. From what I’ve read, this story was not singular.

It also changes the story of the Civil Rights movement. It’s often told as though the movement started in the 1950s. However, with the story of the Silent March, it’s clear that the movement had earlier origins. African Americans were pushing back early and often. There’s never a time when they weren’t trying to change the restricted path that lay before them.

As much as I’d like to claim that I’m aware of all these stories that modify the narrative, I’m not. I read and research, but they’re not as readily available.

That’s where the narrative needs rewriting. Those stories should be weaved through the narrative and should be just as commonly known. The same holds true for the history of Mexican Americans, and Chinese Americans and Japanese Americans, and so on and so forth.

It’s about Agency

It’s not just about adding in Black stories to show them as “victims” of history. As teachers, if we merely discuss the horrors that have been inflicted on marginalized groups, we run the risk of making it seem as though those groups were just reactors to history, not actors in history. We make it seem as though history was done to those who were not in power. Even though there was a significant power imbalance, they were still participants in the storyline. They were still actors, and they still had agency. Events weren’t merely put upon them, and they certainly weren’t just victims.

Our History Reflects Back on US

It’s also not just about conveying a more even narrative. For most students, they only get a chance to glance at history. Think about the subtext when Black people are shown as only victims or passive reactors in history. Some American History includes stories of Black people that are just astonishing awful and sad to read. Those stories do need to be told. However, that story leaves out the agency of Black Americans. It’s an agency that is a part of the narrative – pushing back and propelling history on a different path. It can’t just be separated and sanitized into isolated accomplishments. They were (and are) part of American History and influenced its path.

I’m sure some history teachers are doing this already. However, those teachers who don’t have as much of a background in history might not be aware of the more inclusive narrative that exists. After all, much of it is not included in textbooks (particularly those written for the elementary and middle school levels), and teachers don’t usually have time to do that research independently.

With this dialogue, I’m not really speaking to history professors at the college level or even teachers at the high school level. Instead, I’m speaking to those of us who teach at the younger levels, most especially in middle school. We might be a child’s earliest interaction with a history that moves beyond a simplistic story.

What’s Next?

Therefore, I challenge you to try mixing up the narrative with just one of your units. Look carefully at the story you’re telling. What’s missing? How could that tale be more accurately and effectively portrayed? What could you have your students read? What questions can you ask? How do you want your students to see American History?

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Comments

  1. 1

    Katie says

    February 25, 2019 at 12:10 pm

    This is such an important post, thank you for sharing! One activity I like to do is have students rewrite the narrative. I have them read a passage in their textbook and then I give them mostly primary and some secondary sources that share information that has been left out. Students then use the documents to rewrite the textbook passage. One example I do is Nat Turner, who gets about a paragraph in our textbook. I think I’ll have to add Woodrow Wilson to the list.

    Reply
    • 2

      peacefieldhistory says

      February 25, 2019 at 7:00 pm

      That’s a really good lesson idea!

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Teaching History from an Anti-Racist Lens - Peacefield History says:
    October 9, 2019 at 6:28 am

    […] previously wrote about this topic when I discussed how Black History Month wasn’t Enough. The narrative of U.S. History was originally written by those whose voices were most dominant. A […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Peacefield History

Peacefield History is filled with all topics teaching and history related. Follow me for trends in education, teacher tech tips, history related reading, and other more general musings.

Search

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Join the Facebook Group

Follow Me on Pinterest

Instagram

peacefieldhistory

I had a small win this Friday, and I needed it thi I had a small win this Friday, and I needed it this week. I told my AP students that I was excited about this quiz idea, and they laughed. Honestly, there’s not much to look forward to in a pandemic, and if an exciting quiz is it, well so be it. 

I took the idea of hexagonal review and turned it into a quiz. It was assigned in Google Slides, and I could see the minute they start editing, and the minute they finished. This also worked remotely, and it even worked for my students who have iffy internet. Zoom in to read the directions, and let me know if you have questions. (My Kardashian example is an inside joke with my AP kids.) 

#socialstudies #iteachhistory #iteachAP #socialstudiesteachersrock #iteachmiddleschool #iteachhistory #socialstudiestips #remoteteaching #hybridteaching
You are watching an insurrection. This is domesti You are watching an insurrection. 
This is domestic terrorism. 
This is not a representative Democracy. 

Period.
𝗝𝘂𝘀𝘁 𝗮𝘀𝗸𝗶𝗻𝗴???? ⁣ 𝗝𝘂𝘀𝘁 𝗮𝘀𝗸𝗶𝗻𝗴???? ⁣
⁣
I don't think we should be first on the list by any means... however, when I see teachers from other states getting that coveted shot in their arm, I wonder when it will be our turn. ⁣
⁣
I just want some information.⁣
⁣
#socialstudiesteacher #socialstudies #teachinghistory  #hybridlearning #weareteachers #teacherlife #middleschoolsteacher #teachersfollowteachers  #distancelearning #iteachhistory #
This post might be two days late, but that's becau This post might be two days late, but that's because I'm all about finding "balance" this year. Balance between...⁣
⁣
work/life⁣
school/home⁣
plenty/simplicity⁣
productivity/relaxation⁣
the past/ the future⁣
growth/contentment⁣
⁣
I can over think everything at every moment of the day. This year, I just want to live and savor the days instead. (This might just be because I'm 40 now, but I see those days as they pass, and they are fast y'all.)⁣
⁣
#socialstudiesteacher #socialstudies #teachinghistory #TpT #teacherspayteachers #teacherlife #middleschoolteacher #teachersfollowteachers  #distancelearning #iteachhistory #distancelearning  #engagingteaching #historyteacher #iteachmiddleschool #iteachAP #teacheronbreak
Accurate. Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to t Accurate.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to those who celebrate in this season! I’m just trying not to eat ALL the spinach and artichoke dip that I made... #selfcare #thedipistheselfcare
My students have been playing "For Crown or Colony My students have been playing "For Crown or Colony?" over the past week, and I needed a new way to make sure that they were understanding/paying attention to what they were learning from the game. I wanted this check-in to be quick, easy to mark, and with minimal clicking on my part. @Padlet came to my rescue. Here's how I set it up.⁣
⁣
1. I posted a question with directions. My post was the only item visible on the page.⁣
2. Student didn't have to log in, they just created their own posts and added their names at the top. ⁣
3. To prevents students from copying each other, I make the posts require approval. This way, I could see all the posts, but they could not. I could provide a check next to their names as I gradually approved the posts. ⁣
⁣
This worked. Students would review the posts the next day to see how their interactions with the game differed. It was easy and quick, and we all need more of that this year. I hope you're thriving and not just surviving right now in your classroom!⁣
⁣
Allison⁣
⁣
#socialstudiesteacher #socialstudies #teachinghistory #TpT #teacherspayteachers #hybridlearning #teacherlife #middleschoolsteacher #teachersfollowteachers #historyteacher #distancelearning #iteachhistory #distancelearning #cooperativelearning #padlet #missionus #forcrownorcolony  #iteachmiddleschool
So basically today was about how much I look like So basically today was about how much I look like my Bitmoji. 🤷🏻‍♀️ #greatkidslongyear #iteachmiddleschool #socialstudiesteacher #iteachhistory #hybridteaching #socialstudies #bitmoji #teachersofinstagram
I'm EXHAUSTED, but I'm starting to figure out how I'm EXHAUSTED, but I'm starting to figure out how this hybrid learning thing works. (It probably helps that I have the sweetest kids under the sun this year!) Since I've had a couple nights of actual sleep, I decided to blog about some of the ideas I've had for cooperative learning this year. It's definitely more difficult, but it's not impossible. (Especially since I've fallen in love with Google Breakout rooms.) Click the link in my profile to learn more!
I have a million tasks on my plate right now, but I have a million tasks on my plate right now, but I may have spent some of my Saturday rearranging my plants. Swipe to see some of my faves. (Yes I have fave plants, don’t you?!) 

#noregrets #havetograde #plantsaremyhappyplace #plantlady #houseplants #sundayvibes #homedecor #sundayscaries
The day after the President told teachers that the The day after the President told teachers that they were focusing too much on slavery in our history, we talked about slavery in my AP class. Why? It's a HUGE part of U.S. History, and not shocking, it also a HUGE part of my curriculum. Slavery comes up often in my classes because it's so fundamental to our development as a country. I'd traditionally done this lesson as a silent conversation, however, I decided to have my hybrid class use Jamboard instead for this lesson.  I gave them 8 "thought provoking" prompts. They had to respond using the ideas they generated by reading two articles (Nash and Kendi). Then, they had to respond to a classmate's posts on each slide. ⁣
⁣
It was an intense and silent period. Students were clicking, typing and THINKING. Their brains were flying and focused. It was interesting, when the bell rang it startled all of this. The initial feedback was that they really enjoyed the experience. We had nine slides filled with details and ideas. Of all that I have done with hybrid teaching thus far, this was probably my favorite. ⁣
⁣
I had a bit of a lightbulb go off with this experience. We're often tasks with "summing things up" at the end of every lesson. With this lesson, I made it about the PROCESS. Thinking, critical thinking, doesn't always lead to an immediate resolution. My students still learned, despite not having a summation.⁣
⁣
This is not my lesson. I've blogged about it previously, and all the resources are there. Click the link in my profile to grab them.
I had another post scheduled for this evening, but I had another post scheduled for this evening, but right now all I can think about is this tremendous loss and my concern for our country. She lived an admirable life, and the fears we have because of her death make me so sad. 

Image from @theimpeccablewoman
Since many of us teaching remotely in some form th Since many of us teaching remotely in some form these days,  I compiled a list of my favorite Youtube channels for teaching Middle School History.  You can check out my blog post by clicking the link in my profile.
One of the best things I did for myself this past One of the best things I did for myself this past year was revive my garden. It had fallen to pieces the previous year. I was overwhelmed by life, and the garden was way too big for just me. It had become a place of stress instead of joy. This year, I cut it in half and had my Dad help me rebuild the beds. With a smaller garden, I was able to maintain the space properly. It looks so much better, I grew veggies and flowers again, and I love going out there now!

Never forget to keep a space for yourself. Both a tangible space and one in your mind.
I had the BEST day with students today. I introduc I had the BEST day with students today. I introduced them to @pear_deck, and we were all able to collectively learn. They learned about the program, and I learned a bit more about them! I gave them a bunch of different kinds of questions to get them used to the platform. For one, they had to draw a historical event, and then their classmates had to guess which even they were drawing. I faced my  computer towards the screen so that both my in class students and my remote students could participate. It was so cool! Everyone had a chance to be a part of the conversation.

I still look serious here however, because despite these positive experiences, we all have to stay vigilant. Keep cleaning, socially distancing, and keep that mask on! I want to at least keep hybrid schooling in my life, and that will only happen if our cases stay low.

Get some rest this weekend!
So, my first day back with students went by in a f So, my first day back with students went by in a flash, so here’s a picture from the morning before the school day.

Honestly, for me today was pretty darn good. To see my AP kids in the room was just pure joy (I had them in seventh also.) The hybrid thing was weird, but we’ll get used to it. The seventh graders were still super cute - online or in person - and we all just seemed happy to be back. I know that it’s going to get more difficult, and I think that grading online is certainly going to kill me. However, I’m going to savor this moment. I just felt grateful to be back in my classroom. (Oh, and wearing a mask really wasn’t that bad.🤷🏻‍♀️)

I hope your day was good also, and if it wasn’t, I hope it gets better soon!
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Categories

  • AP U.S. History
  • Assessment
  • Book Reviews
  • Classroom Management
  • Digital Learning
  • Inquiry Based Learning
  • Lessons
  • Professional Development
  • Standards Based Grading
  • Teacher Budgeting
  • Teacher Interviews
  • Teacher Self Care
  • Teacher Tech
  • Teaching Strategies
  • Teaching the Election

Popular Posts

  • Designing your Social Studies Classroom Cheaply and Easily
    Designing your Social Studies Classroom Cheaply and Easily
  • 4 Fun Websites for Teaching Geography Interactively
    4 Fun Websites for Teaching Geography Interactively
  • 10 Hacks for Creating with Google Slides - Part 1
    10 Hacks for Creating with Google Slides - Part 1
  • Eight Youtube Channels for Teaching Middle School Social Studies
    Eight Youtube Channels for Teaching Middle School Social Studies
  • Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies
    Utilizing MEAL for Paragraph Writing in Social Studies
  • 10 Cooperative Learning Idea for a Socially Distanced Classroom
    10 Cooperative Learning Idea for a Socially Distanced Classroom
  • My Favorite History Review Game of All Time!
    My Favorite History Review Game of All Time!
  • The Best Inquiry Based Social Studies Lessons on the Web
    The Best Inquiry Based Social Studies Lessons on the Web
  • A Critical Thinking One Pager Assessment
    A Critical Thinking One Pager Assessment
  • 8 (More) Podcasts for History Teachers
    8 (More) Podcasts for History Teachers

Find me on Facebook

Find me on Facebook

© 2018–2021 Peacefield History.
  • Contact Me
  • Privacy Policy